Shame vs Guilt. The Roots of Healthy Self-Esteem

By Keith York LMFT, Director of The East Bay Center for Relational Recovery

As a therapist, I often meet clients struggling with the deep belief that they are "not enough"—not good enough, smart enough, attractive enough, or worthy of love. These internal narratives are not random. They are often rooted in something called toxic shame.

But what exactly is shame—and how is it different from guilt? And how do these emotional experiences shape the very core of our self-esteem?

Let’s break it down.

Guilt: "I Did Something Bad"

Guilt is the feeling we experience when we've done something wrong. It’s behavior-focused: I made a mistake, I hurt someone, I failed to live up to my values.

Guilt can be incredibly useful. Healthy guilt helps us remain accountable and fosters repair in relationships. It is a normal and useful emotion that tells our brains: “I need to make this right.” Guilt affirms that while we may have done something wrong, we are not fundamentally flawed.

In other words, guilt—when it’s appropriate—is an ally of emotional growth and healthy self-esteem. Guilt is being able to feel proportionately bad about our behavior while still holding ourselves in warm regard as a flawed human being.

Shame: "I Am Something Bad"

Shame, on the other hand, is identity-based. It doesn’t say I made a mistake, it says I am the mistake. Shame leaves no room for repair because it attacks the self, not just the behavior.

Toxic shame is the core driver of many mental health struggles, from depression and anxiety to addiction and intimacy issues. Toxic shame doesn't teach; it paralyzes. It convinces us that we are unlovable, unworthy, and broken beyond repair.

Shame is "lethal" to self-esteem. When we internalize shame, we develop a negative self-image that feels permanent. This emotional wound often originates in childhood experiences—through neglect, criticism, trauma, or being made to feel invisible or “too much.”

How Shame and Guilt Affect Self-Esteem

Healthy self-esteem doesn't come from never failing—it comes from knowing we are worthy even when we fail. Guilt allows for that distinction. Shame does not.

In fact, shame and low self-esteem feed each other in a vicious cycle. When we feel ashamed, we isolate. We stop reaching out, stop taking risks, stop showing up as our authentic selves. The more we hide, the more disconnected we become—from others and from ourselves.

And over time, we mistake that disconnection for proof of our unworthiness.

Healing Shame: Moving Toward Healthy Self-Esteem

Here at The East Bay Center for Relational Recovery we teach people that healing shame requires connection. “We are wounded in relationship, and we heal in relationship.”

Here are a few principles that can help shift from shame to self-worth:

1. Name It to Tame It

   Recognize when shame is showing up. Ask: Is this about what I did—or who I think I am? Bringing awareness to shame is the first step to disarming it.

2. Practice Relational Mindfulness

   Relational skills are not innate—they are learned. Part of developing self-esteem is learning how to stay connected to others without abandoning ourselves. This includes assertiveness, boundary-setting, and compassion.

3. Challenge the Inner Critic

   Shame thrives in secrecy. When we begin to speak about our experiences—whether in therapy, support groups, or close relationships—we start to see ourselves through kinder eyes. The critical voice loses its grip when we stop taking it as truth.

4. Build a Pro-Relationship Self

   We all have parts of us that are adaptive but ultimately self-defeating—we call this your "adaptive child." Healing involves nurturing our wise adult self, the part of us capable of intimacy, responsibility, and truth-telling.

   
   

You Are Not the Problem

Here at EBCRR we want you to understand that you are not the problem—your adaptations are. And those can change.

Guilt says: You can do better.

Shame says: You are no good.

But healing says: You are human—and that’s enough.

Reclaiming self-esteem means learning to live from a place of worthiness, not perfection. It means recognizing that mistakes are part of the human experience, not a referendum on our value.

If you’ve been living under the weight of shame, know this: you are not alone—and you don’t have to stay there.

If this resonated with you, we here at EBCRR invite you to reach out. Our center’s practice is grounded in helping individuals move from self-criticism to self-connection—and we’d be honored to walk with you on that journey.

Appointments